Humble Pie
📍 1115 Howell Mill Rd NW, Atlanta, GA 30318, USA
Weighted rating from:
Google: 4.8 • TripAdvisor: 4
JetlyGo Score
Score calculated from online mentions, review sentiment, and dining indicators across Atlanta. Trust this score to find where to eat, drink, and dine in Atlanta.
Available amenities(13)
Based on verified guest experiences
Offers:Check back later for deals at Humble Pie
Humble Pie in Atlanta, United States, is a delightful eatery that beautifully blends a warm atmosphere with a diverse menu. Known for its impressive pizza selection, including the popular short rib Philly and various creative toppings, it has garnered a loyal following among locals and visitors alike. The restaurant's inviting ambiance, complemented by attentive service, makes it an ideal spot for everything from casual lunches to family dinners. With a focus on quality ingredients and an extensive drink menu, Humble Pie caters to a variety of diners, including families, couples, and business groups, ensuring a memorable dining experience. Its blend of Italian and American cuisines, along with features like outdoor seating and full bar service, enhances its charm. The positive feedback from patrons reflects a strong reputation for both food and service, solidifying its place as a must-visit destination in Atlanta.
Signature Dishes
- •Short Rib Philly Pizza
- •Pepperoni Pizza
- •Crab Hushpuppies
- •Shrimp Scampi Pizza
- •Not So Humble Fries
- •Jumbo House Wings
Overall rating 4.7 / 5 (1,674 reviews)
Google: 4.8 (1479 reviews)
TripAdvisor: 4 (195 reviews)
Customer Reviews
Walked over to eat here while waiting on our reserved tee-time. Server was very attentive. Greeted with smiles upon arrival. Food was good. The portions of low-averaged size (wings). Pizza was okay. Will try the meat one next time. Wedges were plentiful and really good.
We had high expectations for the Humble Pie, based on excellent online reviews. Ultimately, the Humble pie underdelivered. Here are the details: Ambiance & Service: A The open, airy, and welcoming décor was a real plus. Service was courteous and attentive. Appetizer – Jumbo House Wings: C- Totally pedestrian… truly nothing special. You can find better wings at Wing Stop. Appetizer – Not So Humble Fries: B+ I’m partial to thick, bulgy fries, yet these were quite thin. But they were good… flavorful and crunchy. Entrees – Steak and Eggs: D+ We ordered the steak medium rare, yet it arrived well done. Very little flavor to this dish… You can eat better steak and eggs at IHOP. Entrées – 2 Pizzas: B We ordered both the Short Rib Philly and the Carnivore. Both were decent to good, but a far cry from special. Mocktail – Mojito: C+ It was basically lemonade… I also was disappointed with the menu. We arrived at 11:45am and expected to order from their single “All-Day” menu. Yet because it was before 12pm, we were forced to order from their brunch menu. Excuse me? Why is it called “All-Day” menu if it’s not really all-day? And it was only 10 to 15 minutes before noon and exceptions can’t be made? Before tipping, we paid $130.68 for our meal (3 people, water, one mocktail, 2 appetizers, 3 entrees, no dessert, no alcohol). Ultimately, we expected at 5-star experience and were given a 3-star meal at best. We will not be returning.
We ordered a pepperoni, mushroom, and chicken on the Cauliflower crust and it was simply amazing. The meats, sauce, and cheese worked together wonderfully and the crust was perfectly light and crispy. Amazing! We also got a side salad, which was also amazing, it was just a side salad! We will definitely be going back next time we visit Scottsdale
Excellent pizza!! Best sourdough crust, and fresh, tasty pizza. However, service is not so excellent, in fact, our server was indignant and rude. So... great pizza, horrible service = order takeout